From the indie anthems of Hot Fuss to the intimate storytelling of Pressure Machine, we rank The Killers’ seven studio albums and their B-sides compilation Sawdust from worst to best.
Having recently ranked the 25 best Killers songs and found myself thoroughly enjoying their back catalogue, the next natural step was to rank their albums. From their debut Hot Fuss to their most recent studio album, Pressure Machine, with the B-sides and rarities compilation Sawdust thrown in for good measure, there's plenty to get through. And then there's the daunting, near-impossible task of deciding which is better: Sam's Town or Hot Fuss?
8) Wonderful Wonderful (2017)
Putting something like this last almost feels like cheating, but something has to come bottom, and unfortunately, it's Wonderful Wonderful. Leading with 'The Man', which would become one of The Killers' most memorable, show-stopping, bravado-filled walk-on tracks, the album finds the band exploring a breezier, synth-pop sound that ebbs and flows throughout. It has a special place in my heart for several reasons, chief among them being that the Wonderful Wonderful tour was the first time I saw The Killers live (certainly not the last). There's also the involvement of Alex Cameron, who contributed to tracks including 'Run for Cover', a song originally written during the Day & Age sessions that finally found a home here.
Dire Straits vocalist and guitarist Mark Knopfler lends his talents to 'Have All the Songs Been Written?', while Flowers draws on his sporting fandom for 'Tyson vs Douglas', inspired by the famous 1990 boxing match and the question of what happens when a hero falls. Flowers, for all his faults, has never been particularly guarded. He lays every emotion on the table, sometimes sentimental, sometimes corny, and that vulnerability is all over this record. It's a beautiful, occasionally uneven album that helped kickstart a reappraisal of The Killers in its own right.
7) Day & Age (2008)
I like this one. It had the daunting task of following the critical and commercial successes of Hot Fuss and Sam's Town, while preparing The Killers for the arena and stadium shows that would come to define their career. And it's got some stone-cold bangers. 'Spaceman'. 'Human'. 'Are we human, or are we dancer?' Simple, yet revolutionary. It's more pop-oriented than what came before, playful in places, but still capable of delivering something as earnest and emotionally devastating as 'A Dustland Fairytale', which hits like a freight train of nostalgia.
The sound is bigger, certainly, but what's impressive is how the band manages to reconcile its very British and very American influences. How do you take a group that owes so much to British new wave and turn it into a stadium-filling American rock band? Day & Age provides the answer, with new wave dance songs that sounded like classics upon arrival. Ranking this second from bottom almost feels like heresy. It's their 'throw everything at the wall and see what sticks' album, and, well, an awful lot of it sticks.
6) Battle Born (2012)
Springsteen again. But the '80s nostalgia is particularly evident here, with a love letter to fabulous Las Vegas that draws on Tom Petty's storytelling and David Bowie's theatricality. 'Miss Atomic Bomb' and 'Runaways' are as banging as they come. The longing, the yearning, the almost childlike nostalgia: it's really hard to hate an album that gives us tracks like these. There's something different about Battle Born, though. It finds the band entering another chapter of their career, fully embracing the enormous, widescreen sound they'd been working towards.
Rolling Stone readers voted it their second-favourite album of 2012, and it's easy to understand why. The Killers have gone for stadium-sized gold here. They only really know how to be epic, and while the quieter touches of their earlier work are sometimes missed, there's plenty to enjoy in the Soft Cell-inspired theatricality of 'Heart of a Girl' and the fireworks of 'From Here on Out'. It's heavy on the Meat Loaf, too, and I mean that as a compliment. The album's sincerity, its unapologetic earnestness and its commitment to making absolutely everything sound enormous are what make it so likeable.
5) Sawdust (2007)
This B-sides and rarities compilation had no right to be as good as it was. If this is what didn't make the records, what on earth did? You know you're doing something right when you can open with a Lou Reed collaboration and somehow things get even better from there. 'Tranquilize', 'The Ballad of Michael Valentine', 'All the Pretty Faces', 'Show You How'... Oh my God.
It's effortlessly undervalued, about as underrated as a Killers release can get. There's the finale to the band's murder trilogy, 'Leave the Bourbon on the Shelf', and 'Glamorous Indie Rock & Roll', an anthem built for stadiums, full of that sweeping earnestness The Killers do so well. Sawdust shows us that what's left on the cutting-room floor isn't always worth discarding. Even their leftovers are capable of producing moments of sheer brilliance. And then there's their inspired cover of Dire Straits' 'Romeo and Juliet', which I was lucky enough to hear live. That alone earns this compilation a special place in my heart.
4) Imploding the Mirage (2020)
The album that made the pandemic somewhat bearable. Imploding the Mirage was The Killers' arena record, released at a time when playing arenas was impossible. There's something strangely fitting about that. 'My Own Soul's Warning' and 'Caution' are as memorable as anything they've recorded, while the heartbreaking 'My God' features contributions from Weyes Blood and Lucius. The band also enlisted artist Thomas Blackshear for the album artwork, giving the record a suitably grand, spiritual Western aesthetic.
Musically, it returns to the Springsteen and E Street Band influences that have followed The Killers throughout their career, with a mixture of synths, love, redemption and salvation. Their first album without guitarist Dave Keuning also sees them opening the doors to a host of collaborators, resulting in a record that feels both familiar and refreshed. There's a particular kinship with The War on Drugs, especially on 'Blowback', with its expansive, driving sound and sense of longing. Adam Granduciel's involvement elsewhere on the album only strengthens that connection. It's a record that reaches for something enormous at a time when the world had become very small, and somehow, that makes its ambition all the more affecting.
3) Pressure Machine (2021)
If Sam's Town was The Killers' Born to Run, then Pressure Machine is their Nebraska. A deeply personal record born from the band's inability to tour in 2020, it finds Brandon Flowers turning away from the stadium anthems in favour of something more intimate, reflective and honest. 'Quiet Town' manages to capture the tragedy and complicated history of an entire community in heartbreaking fashion. The album's introspective approach also coincides with the return of Dave Keuning, with harmonica, fiddle and acoustic instrumentation helping to bring these deeply personal stories to life.
And if the Weyes Blood collaboration on Imploding the Mirage wasn't unexpected enough, this time we get Phoebe Bridgers appearing on the beautifully raw 'Runaway Horses'. It's a perfect fit for a record so concerned with ordinary lives, missed opportunities and the weight of the past. None of the tracks from Pressure Machine made it onto my 25 best Killers songs list, but that's because this is an album best experienced as a complete work. Its strength comes from the stories building on one another, creating a portrait of small-town America that's compassionate, uncomfortable and occasionally devastating. It's honest, beautiful and one of the most rewarding things The Killers have ever made.
2) Hot Fuss (2004)
Let's be honest, this album could contain 'Mr. Brightside' and 10 tracks of absolute garbage, and we'd still have to rank it fairly highly. Fortunately, Hot Fuss is so much more than its most famous song. Before the Springsteen influence took over, The Killers were an indie rock band with one foot firmly planted in the British music scene. Hot Fuss captures that moment perfectly, full of the grit, glamour and nervous energy of a band finding its feet. 'Jenny Was a Friend of Mine', 'Smile Like You Mean It', 'Somebody Told Me'. What's not to love? The first two parts of the band's murder trilogy are here, alongside some of the most instantly recognisable indie anthems of the 2000s.
The album earned a place on Rolling Stone's list of the 100 best albums of the decade and was included in 1001 Albums You Must Hear Before You Die. Its reputation has only grown in the years since, helped in no small part by Britain's seemingly endless love affair with 'Mr. Brightside'. As debut albums go, most bands would spend their entire careers wishing they could make something even remotely close to Hot Fuss. It's packed with confidence, enormous hooks and the sort of songs that sound as though they've always existed. And yet, somehow, The Killers managed to follow it with something even better.
1) Sam’s Town (2006)
Sam's Town is their best album. That's not necessarily the popular choice, although it's hardly a controversial one either. Hot Fuss gets the plays, the nostalgia and the seemingly immortal singles, but man, there's so much here that's impossible not to fall in love with. 'Bones' cries out to the wind, while the darker touches of 'Uncle Jonny' work wonders. These are haunting, arresting songs, surrounded by anthems that leave an enormous mark. And then there's 'Read My Mind', which might just be one of the greatest things Brandon Flowers has ever written. Flowers wanted to create an album that captured his journey and the influences that had shaped him, and you can hear that ambition in every corner of the record. The iconic artwork, photographed by Anton Corbijn, perfectly captures the dusty, distinctly American atmosphere that runs throughout.
In scope, Sam's Town feels like The Killers' answer to Born to Run. It's the band taking Springsteen's vision of American life, filtering it through their own experiences and selling it back to Flowers' homeland. The songs are bigger, the influences more pronounced and the band considerably more self-assured. Where Hot Fuss occasionally feels uneven, Sam's Town goes for broke and delivers a remarkably consistent collection of songs. It's a band defying second-album syndrome by refusing to repeat what made its debut successful, choosing instead to pursue something grander and more ambitious. The wonderful world of 'Read My Mind' remains spellbinding, 'When You Were Young' is practically untouchable, and the album as a whole captures The Killers at their most confident and emotionally committed. For me, it's the moment everything came together. The ambition, the songwriting, the influences and the sheer size of the sound. Hot Fuss might have introduced The Killers to the world, but Sam's Town is where they became the band they were always meant to be.