A decade after its release, Bon Iver’s most experimental album remains a source of comfort through heartbreak, personal upheaval and the strange business of growing up.
So the year is 2016. Donald Trump just became the first animal to be elected President of the United States. The UK voted to leave the EU, unleashing nationwide upheaval and societal division. Cambridge Analytica is manipulating the algorithm, forever changing how we receive our news. Have things ever been the same since? Personally, that year, I had just graduated from university. All I knew was the safety of education. Then it had spewed me out into the streets, with no support on where to go or what to do next.
So when this album came, and it came packed full of songs about existential dread and deep dissociation with self, it stirred souls. I remember feeling confused when I heard blown-out muffling, grumbling bass, heavily distorted vocals, instruments that don’t quite sound right. When that’s paired with disjointed, ethereal lyrics describing someone not quite sure how they feel and how they envision the future panning out, everything about a traditional indie folk album felt like it was flipped on its head. And that’s what I think made me, and indeed all of us, fall in love with it. Bon Iver is a philosopher of human melancholy, deep diving into religion, sacred numbers and personal rebirth. If there’s a moment where I need emotional support, whether it's a break-up, death, illness, depression or thoughts of dread, he’s my guy. In case of emergency, break out Bon Iver.
And whilst his earlier self-titled album felt like a road trip I never took across the United States, this album felt like a trip through the nervous system and all the feelings I was suppressing. Justin Vernon just held my hand.
We open with ‘22 (OVER S∞∞N)’, with the words ‘it might be over soon’, a song describing restlessness, not knowing where you stand, just like a 21-year-old girl standing at the entrance to life. And now, as a 31-year-old woman, still not too sure what’s going on. Will she ever know?
‘715 - CR∑∑KS’. A devastating, vulnerable look into heartbreak. ‘God damn turn around now, you’re my A-team’ always catches me off guard. In 2016, when I merely felt the loose sensation of what the song was about, now I understand the stoicism of honesty. After a called-off engagement and a whole rebuilding of self.
‘33 “GOD”’ lights us up, sends us on a path of spiritual and religious enlightenment. Bon Iver usually has songs about a physical space you can point to on a map; this song jumps between time, space and consciousness. I was in High Barnet, in the shower on first listen-through; it was a lovely sunny day. Listening again for this review, I’m in Clapton and feeling cathartic.
‘21 M♢♢N WATER’ teaches the importance of harnessing the energy of the marvellous moon. It sounds like transformation, the opening of a new chapter, a new dawn. The dark night heals and renews for a bright new day. At 21, I looked to drugs and alcohol; at 31, I’m using cinnamon at my doorway to welcome new luck into the month. And a lot of cold plunges. That’s transformation.
‘00000 Million’, ‘Must’ve been forces, put me on those wild courses’. I think everyone has looked up to the sky and questioned whether the universe was testing them. And oh boy, I have, plenty of times. But as life has meandered me down this path and I take stock, I’m cool with where I am. I still have no idea where I’m going or what I’m doing, but that’s fine.
What does this album greet 10 years later? The Democrats are starting slowly to win back the United States, after 10 years of a bizarre, terrifying dictatorship from Trump. Basic human rights have been stripped; we’ve watched war break out across the world. We watch heartless genocide take place. Natural disasters and data centres. In the UK, we’re living in a never-ending recession; our livelihoods have been left in the hands of constant substitutions of prime ministers, no one taking the blame for the mess that has been made. But a new leader promises improvement.
I think this album is an instruction manual for how things will be alright if you just persist with living. As I stated before, Bon Iver has been there for me before, and no doubt he will be there when I need him next. Ask me in another 10 years.