20 years of melodic guitars, lovelorn lyrics and a five-star resort on the moon inform our ranking of the 25 best Arctic Monkeys songs.
In 2006, I lived in a small studio apartment in downtown Sacramento, California, took classes at the community college, and worked at a local record store. I was the coolest I’d ever been, but was too insecure to notice.
Emo and indie sleaze were big at the time. I spent most afternoons at the record store slingin’ My Chemical Romance and The Strokes CDs to high school kids sneaking off campus during their lunch break. Everyone was either too cool to be bothered or wearing their emotions on their sleeve.
Arctic Monkeys crashed onto the scene like a breath of fresh UK air. Big guitars and smartass lyrics sung through a heavy British accent. I was hooked. I couldn’t get over the album cover for Whatever People Say I Am, That’s What I’m Not. Just some guy smoking a cigarette. It was so effortlessly cool. In my early 20s, that’s what I wanted to present to the world more than anything.
I had moved past the teenage years of outwardly pouring my heart onto the floor, but now I had to contend with the confusions of young adulthood. Not knowing how to talk to someone you fancied, hopelessly falling in love or lust, being painfully aware of what others are saying about you. Arctic Monkeys had a song for all of it. They were the first band I fell hard for as an adult. 20 years on, I still haven’t lost an ounce of love for them. From the snarky ‘I Bet You Look Good on the Dancefloor’ to the overtly sophisticated ‘Sculptures of Anything Goes’, we’ve grown up together. The irony of being the same age as the band's members doesn’t escape me.
I can find something to like about nearly every one of their songs, which has made narrowing down the top 25 extremely difficult. I’m sure some of these rankings will be controversial; everyone has opinions about the Arctic Monkeys’ catalogue, but I have my reasons. When I finally saw Arctic Monkeys live for the first time, it was truly the antithesis of 20 years of adoration. I will freely admit I cried a little. Now that I’m older, like the band themselves, maybe I’m not afraid to look a little uncool sometimes.
25) Library Pictures
I wasn’t going to include ‘Library Pictures’ on the list, but I couldn’t resist the crude brilliance of ‘Give me an eeny-meeny-miny-moe. Or an ipp dipp, dog-shit rock and roll.’ I’d forgotten how strategically loud early Arctic Monkeys could be. The boisterousness of twenty-something-year-old men trying to leave their mark on the world.
24) Don’t Sit Down ’Cause I’ve Moved Your Chair
Speaking of strategically loud. ‘Don’t Sit Down ’Cause I’ve Moved Your Chair’ sounds like early ’90s Seattle. Although it’s somewhat of a departure from where the band was heading with Suck It and See, it still has Alex Turner’s signature clever lyrics.
23) Piledriver Waltz
Suck It and See is when Arctic Monkeys started getting overtly melodic, and I’m so happy they did. You can revel in the heavy guitars of your 20s for only so long before they start to sound like an imitation. ‘Piledriver Waltz’ sounds like the phrase, ‘I just don’t want anything serious right now.’ The shitty excuse you saw coming months ago, but it’s still such a letdown when it gets here.
22) Snap Out of It
I firmly stand by my opinion that AM is a breakup album. The genius of ‘Snap Out of It’ and AM as a whole is that it doesn’t wallow in self-pity. It explores all aspects of a breakup, including what it sounds like when you were the problem, and your ex has moved on to something better.
21) Why’d You Only Call Me When You’re High?
‘Why’d You Only Call Me When You’re High?’ is so fun, but in true Arctic Monkeys fashion, it’s too clever for its own good. You might think Turner is the one asking the question, but you soon realise he’s actually trying to answer it. How do you make ‘I think about you when I’m fucked up’ sound flattering?
20) When the Sun Goes Down
I forgot how dark this song’s video is. ‘When the Sun Goes Down’ borrows from the grunge tradition of turning heavy subject matter into a catchy rock anthem. While abuse isn’t something any of us likes to think about, this song eases us into it like taking a pill.
19) Fluorescent Adolescent
This is the most Arctic Monkeys have sounded like The Strokes. Which was probably by design; Alex Turner is an unabashed superfan. ‘Fluorescent Adolescent’ is one of a few songs I included on this list because of just how solid it is. It’s one of those songs you don’t necessarily think about that often, but when you hear it, you think, ‘Oh yeah, I forgot how much I like this.’
18) Crying Lightning
‘Crying Lightning’ is like a noir film. The opening bassline and crashing cymbals create a mystery that Alex Turner’s lyrics strategically break apart as the song progresses. We’re all leggy blondes that probably killed our husbands. Turner wants to get to the bottom of our turmoil, and we’ll gladly let him.
17) Brianstorm
Queens of the Stone Age have ‘Song for the Dead’, and Arctic Monkeys have ‘Brianstorm’. Any rock band worth its salt has a song in its catalogue that screams, ‘DRUMS!’ ‘Brianstorm’ just also happens to scream, ‘GUITARS!’
16) Black Treacle
You can’t write a best of Arctic Monkeys list without gushing over Alex Turner’s lyrics. ‘Black Treacle’ is another Arctic Monkeys song that reminds you how much you love it every time you hear it, and it’s a perfect example of how brilliant a songwriter Alex Turner is. There’s so much intelligence packed into the lyrics of this song, but it never goes over your head. It’s like the subtly cool kid stood up in English class one day and blew everyone’s mind.
15) Fireside
‘And I thought I was yours forever, or maybe I was mistaken. But I just cannot manage to make it through the day without thinking of you, lately.’ Does it get more casually devastating? ‘Fireside’ illustrates the point in a breakup where hurt and confusion become routine. You’ve accepted that melancholy is a part of your everyday life. This song is almost the flipside to ‘505’. The madness has dissipated but the longing is still there.
14) Suck It and See
Do I know what the title and chorus of ‘Suck It and See’ mean? No. Do I care? Also, no. This song is pure cheek, which is what makes it so wonderful. The sharpest lyrics you’ve ever heard combined with the catchiest guitar riffs. ‘That’s not a skirt, girl, that’s a sawed-off shotgun. And I can only hope you’ve got it aimed at me.’ Come on! You can’t help but love this song!
13) Do I Wanna Know?
Confession: ‘Do I Wanna Know?’ is my morning alarm. It’s so big and recognisable but effortlessly smooth. This is when Arctic Monkeys shot into the stratosphere. AM officially broke the band in the US and any other small corner of the world they hadn’t managed to conquer. Arenas full of fans still sing this song. I occasionally watch Arctic Monkeys’ 2013 Glastonbury headline set with envy that I wasn’t there.
12) I Wanna Be Yours
Based on a poem by John Cooper Clarke, ‘I Wanna Be Yours’ is one of the only Arctic Monkeys songs with lyrics not strictly written by Alex Turner. Clarke is one of Turner's favourite poets, which is evident when you compare this song to the rest of the band’s catalogue. I wouldn’t put it past Turner to tell someone he wants to be their vacuum cleaner. He can yearn with the best of them.
11) There’d Better Be a Mirrorball
I know people have opinions about Tranquility Base Hotel & Casino and The Car. Both albums were big swings, and while Tranquility Base Hotel & Casino didn’t quite land, The Car definitely did. ‘There’d Better Be a Mirrorball’ encapsulates the audience’s letdown of the previous album. If this is all we get, there better be something shiny.
10) Stop the World I Wanna Get Off with You
‘Stop the World I Wanna Get Off with You’ knows exactly what it's doing. Flirty to the point of being a little dirty, it’s the ultimate proposition. Stretching the tension of ‘Hey, do you wanna get out of here?’ until it almost breaks.
9) R U Mine?
A standout on an album full of standouts, ‘R U Mine?’ showcases just how tight and disciplined Arctic Monkeys had become at this point. A spectacular showcase of Matt Helders’ drumming and Alex Turner’s lyrics, this song is just plain sexy. Really, the whole AM album is just plain sexy. It’s the perfect makeout record.
8) I Bet You Look Good on the Dancefloor
‘I Bet You Look Good on the Dancefloor’ crashed through 2006 like the Kool-Aid Man. It had no business being this damn good; quite frankly, it still doesn’t. It’s like lightning in a bottle. My goodness, was this song one hell of an introduction.
7) She’s Thunderstorms
‘She’s Thunderstorms’ is so stealthy; you hardly realise you’re listening to a love song. Its opening guitar riff is simple yet incredibly effective; it’s catchy and melodic like something you’d hear in a children’s song. The lyrics are boyish and innocent but also hint at something a little more seductive just under the surface. A sentiment that’s mirrored in the guitar solo. This whole song makes you feel butterflies in your tummy.
6) Sculptures of Anything Goes
Over the past 20 years, Arctic Monkeys have evolved extraordinarily, and I’m so glad The Car is where they ended up. One of the biggest complaints about Tranquility Base Hotel & Casino was that Matt Helders’ signature drums were largely absent. ‘Sculptures of Anything Goes’ more than makes up for that mistake. The foreboding is beautiful. It’s like being trapped in a horror movie on the French Riviera. Turner flips his lyrics back on himself, quoting his own bad press. The band took the ashes of their misstep and turned it into something exquisite.
5) Knee Socks
I’m going to go out on a limb and say the opening riff of ‘Knee Socks’ is one of the most recognisable of the past 15 years. Just the mere hint of it causes audiences to go feral. Which is fitting because the song itself is quite feral. On an album that already oozes sex, this song is extra sweaty. Add in Josh Homme’s vocal swagger, and we’re all going to need a shower.
4) The Hellcat Spangled Shalalala
‘The Hellcat Spangled Shalalala’ is my absolute favourite Arctic Monkeys song. ‘Makes me want to blow the candles out just to see if you glow in the dark’ is also my absolute favourite Alex Turner lyric. I understand there’s a difference between what I personally love in a song and what makes a song overall best, which is why ‘The Hellcat Spangled Shalalala’ is ranked number four on this list. Arctic Monkeys are at their best when they’re writing about love. This song is proof. It’s the frog that jumps into your throat every time you see your crush. It’s the gauzy haze that envelops the world when you’re falling in love. The opening guitar jangle makes my heart so damn happy. Turner’s voice has a sweetness that isn’t necessarily heard in other songs; it almost tells you exactly who he’s singing about.
3) Love Is a Laserquest
I didn’t anticipate putting ‘Love Is a Laserquest’ in the top three on this list, but it really doesn’t belong anywhere else. From the opening drumbeat to the last twang of the guitar, ‘Love Is a Laserquest’ is a haunting open wound. It’s lying awake at 2:30 in the morning, being honest with yourself in the dark. As I said before, Arctic Monkeys are at their best when writing about love. That doesn’t necessarily mean songs about falling in love. I might prefer their songs about losing love more. ‘Love Is a Laserquest’ is a quiet gut punch, but it’s also remarkably cathartic.
2) 505
There’s no way ‘505’ was going to rank any lower than the top two. This song is maximum yearn. It’s the horny little ghost that tiptoes around the back of your mind until you can’t take it anymore, and every lustful thought and feeling you’ve ever had bursts out of your body. Moving from soft and controlled to chaos, ‘505’ crescendos with ‘I crumble completely when you cry.’ Like the lyrics, the song is falling apart. Desperately clinging to what used to be. Seven-hour flight, forty-five-minute drive; I will get back there.
1) Arabella
Alex Turner has said the lyrics to ‘Arabella’ are about a specific person. To my knowledge, no one has ever described my lips as ‘the galaxy’s edge’, or my kiss as ‘the colour of a constellation fallin’ into place’, and that hurts my soul a little. If there is anything better than an Arctic Monkeys song about love, it’s an Arctic Monkeys song about lust. This song trickles down the back of your neck like a bead of sweat. It glides and sways like a Latin dancer. ‘Arabella’ combines the best of Arctic Monkeys. Grungy guitars, pawing lyrics, and an expansive soundscape.