The 25 Best Songs by Fiona Apple, Ranked

Thirty years of keeping it real: Charting Fiona Apple’s 25 best songs

‘Tact is the art of saying nothing when there’s nothing to say, so I have tact. It’s not that I’m shy,’ said the then 19-year-old Fiona Apple to The Tonight Show’s Jay Leno in 1997. It was shortly after the release of Tidal, the critically acclaimed album that catapulted her into the spotlight just a year prior.

July of this year marked thirty years since the release of Tidal. Since then, Apple has proven that she lives by the art of selective speech.

I, like most, was introduced to Apple through the captivating ‘Criminal’ music video. I imagine this first watch was thanks to one of those morning music video programmes from VH1 or MTV (I’d let it play on the TV while I got ready for school). Since then, she has become one of my immediate first replies to ‘So, who’s your favourite singer?’

Her lyricism is raw and intentional, pushed through by powerful vocals that sound as though they belong to the dark rooms of jazz clubs. Apple challenged the idea of what it meant to be a solo female artist in the late 90s, much to the chagrin of the media.

She didn’t apologise for being herself, and through her thirty-year career she’s invited us to witness her charting of her place in the world. In a 1997 interview for Interview magazine, Apple proclaimed, ‘I want to be like the patron saint of reality.’

Through her five studio albums spanning the last three decades, Apple has kept her word. Not only is she willing to be vulnerable, but she’s also unapologetic about it. There’s something magnetic about Apple’s unwavering dedication to challenging the status quo. She hit the mainstream at a time when the media wanted nothing more than to control the narrative for young female artists. She famously spoke out against it in her 1997 acceptance speech for ‘Best New Artist’, and she never apologised for it (to the chagrin of the media).

As we hit the peak of autumn, I thought, what better season than to catalogue my personal top 25 Fiona Apple songs? She’s the perfect artist for transitional times, and while this proved to be a more difficult task than I imagined, here’s my best attempt.


25) Tymps (The Sick in the Head Song)

Extraordinary Machine is undoubtedly Apple’s quirkiest album. ‘Tymps (The Sick in the Head Song)’ features what can only be described as a cacophony behind Apple’s signature introspective lyrics. It feels as though we are Mario characters, marching along as she wonders if she’s lost her mind or if it’s just a classic case of lovesickness. The final version of Extraordinary Machine was produced by Mike Elizondo, a producer known for working closely with various rappers and hip-hop legends like Dr. Dre and 50 Cent.

There’s a certain recognisable, funky sound to this album. When I listened to ‘Tymps’ for the first time, I found myself going, ‘Oh yeah, this definitely belongs to that one album with the interesting (teeth?) cover.’


24) Not About Love

Zach Galifianakis feigning animosity towards Fiona Apple to her jazzy, insistent ‘Not About Love’ is something that I, admittedly, didn’t realise was a piece of media until last week.

‘Not About Love’ is an amazing account of what it feels like to reflect on a catastrophic fight with a lover. You say things to one another that you can’t take back, and if it’s bad enough, the images of one another are shattered. The chorus feels like an aside to the listener: ‘This is not about love / ’Cause I am not in love / In fact, I can’t stop falling out.’ She admits that of course, it’s complicated, right before hitting us with a chaotic bridge. I absolutely love that after the rollercoaster that is this song, Apple sheepishly closes with, ‘I miss that stupid ache.’


23) Pale September

I hate to say it because I know it’s overstated, but some albums just fit with the seasons. Tidal is an autumn record. In ‘Pale September’, Apple is shedding her walls and finding warmth in the comfort of feeling like she can be vulnerable with someone new. This is such a beautiful ballad about opening yourself up.




22) The Child Is Gone

‘The Child Is Gone’ is one of the most important songs from Tidal. It serves as a point of reference for the writing that her 42-year-old self put out on Fetch the Bolt Cutters.

The 19-year-old Apple was grappling with coming into herself as a young woman in a media landscape that was particularly adverse towards young female artists. I interpret this song as Apple coming to terms with the fact that she will largely have to navigate her transition into adulthood on her own, leaving her longing for connection, but ultimately pushing it away: ‘Honey help me out of this mess / I’m a stranger to myself / But don’t reach for me, I’m too far away.’


21) Heavy Balloon

‘Heavy Balloon’ is a hidden-in-plain-sight gem off Fetch the Bolt Cutters. The percussion on this song, like the rest of the album, provides the sensation that you are right in the room with Apple.

In ‘Heavy Balloon’, we’re marching with Apple as she compares depression to the heavy balloon that makes us feel tethered to the ground. Despite the constant battle with this heavy balloon, the chorus points us in an uplifting direction: ‘I spread like strawberries / I climb like peas and beans.’

Shortly after the album’s release in 2020, Apple told Vulture that the line above came from a children’s gardening book. It’s a beautiful idea, that despite being weighed down by depression or whatever else tries to keep you down, there’s always room to grow and expand in your own garden.


20) Carrion

Leave it to Apple to have a sultry song where she compares her dying love to that of an animal carcass. The build-up to the chorus crescendos into her insistence: ‘My feel for you boy / Is decaying in front of me / Like the carrion of a murdered prey.’ Apple often plays with power dynamics in relationships, and here it’s interesting to see her grapple with the reality that she in many ways can impart hurt on her former lover.


19) Under the Table

When Fetch the Bolt Cutters was first released back in April of 2020, I was only 20 years old. As a 20-year-old feeling particularly angsty (on account of all the time alone to think), I was struck by Apple’s confident lyricism. Sometimes, I find I have an aversion to lyrics that are too ‘on the nose’, but I find it works so well on this track.

How badass is it to not only proclaim ‘Kick me under the table all you want, I won’t shut up’ to the person who invited you to a dinner you didn’t want to go to, but to then also write an entire song about it where you chant it for the chorus?


19) Never Is a Promise

In a 2012 interview, Apple told New York magazine that she originally wrote ‘Never Is a Promise’ after finding out that the boy she lost her virginity to was interested in another girl. This song feels like a homage to what it means to feel everything deeply as a young adult, coming into yourself.


18) I Know

‘I Know’ elicits images of a brooding Apple, playing the piano in the rear of a jazz bar. She’s found herself in an affair where she ultimately knows that it is unlikely to end in her favour, but she cannot help but keep the door open. ‘I Know’ captures the feeling of unrequited love.


17) Oh Well

From those first piano notes, it’s evident that ‘Oh Well’ is a song born of frustration. It’s as if Apple is singing through gritted teeth, tension at an all-time high. This is my top track from Extraordinary Machine. Apple’s frustrated by every part of the situation she found herself in, leading her to exclaim, ‘What wasted unconditional love / On somebody / Who doesn’t believe in the stuff.’ I love the use of the word ‘stuff’, instead of ‘it’ to refer to unconditional love. It perfectly matches her resignation to the experience. It’s the ‘oh well’ of it all.


16) Shameika

‘Shameika’ is such a fun song off Fetch the Bolt Cutters. The might of her piano playing here is unreal. It feels so aggressive and urgent. Throughout her career, the media has wilfully misunderstood Apple. It’s evident that Apple has also felt misunderstood in her personal life.

In October of 2020, Apple did an incredible live performance of ‘Shameika’ for The New Yorker Festival. This performance is what got me hooked on the song. Apple and her piano are seemingly unified on account of the intensity at which she plays.


15) Get Gone

Apple begins ‘Get Gone’ in a hushed tone with soft piano backing her stern ‘How many times do I have to say / To get away, get gone?’ I love that if you aren’t paying attention to the lyrics for the first minute or so, you might think this is a sweet ballad.

The turn happens with her asking her ex to ‘Put away that meat [he’s] selling’. What better way to say, ‘Get away from me’?


14) Fast as You Can

Apple hits the ground running in ‘Fast as You Can’. I imagine Apple running ahead of an interested suitor, going back and forth with him on how he should be careful around her because he doesn’t know just how ‘crazy’ she is. When she slows down her run and abruptly makes it to the bridge, she reluctantly lets him know, ‘Yeah, I’ll be your pet if you just tell me it’s a gift.’

I love the music video to this one. Apple plays up the ‘crazy’ by staring at the camera with a rictus grin at the end, and just before that she puts a lit match to her mouth like a lollipop.


13) Sullen Girl

‘Sullen Girl’ serves as the backbone of not only Tidal, but of being able to understand Apple’s point of view. At 12 years old, Apple was raped by a stranger in her Manhattan apartment building. ‘Sullen Girl’ is about her experience and how it changed her on a personal level, but also how people perceived her. This complex relationship with her autonomy, sexuality, and image is one that permeates her catalogue. The arrangement of strings as support of the piano makes the intensity of the subject matter visceral.


12) Valentine

I am, admittedly, only featuring two songs from The Idler Wheel… It is the album I turn to least, but it does house two of my favourite Apple songs, one of which is ‘Valentine’. Apparently, this song is about Apple’s admiration towards another woman (admiration with no sapphic undertones). I think it is interesting to consider the lyrics from this perspective. They read as though Apple is a bystander, watching the unidentified woman with envy. Perhaps this woman isn’t even a separate person at all, but rather a version of Apple that she feels she’ll never be able to access. The deep string bass on this song cuts through the background, entering the song as she picks up speed. It’s incredible.


11) Fetch the Bolt Cutters

Shortly after the album’s release, Apple told Vulture that the title track ‘[Is] about breaking out of whatever prison you’ve allowed yourself to live in, whether you built that prison for yourself or whether it was built around you and you just accepted it.’

In ‘Fetch the Bolt Cutters’, Apple reflects on her Tidal years and the ways that she was susceptible to the noise of those around her and the media at large. The song strikes an almost maternal nerve, with the now wiser Apple extending compassion to her younger self while also giving her present self the permission to cut herself loose.


10) Werewolf

So, we’ve reached the murky waters of (my) top ten Fiona Apple songs. We’ve also reached my second favourite song from The Idler Wheel… It opens with some of my favourite lyrics from her: ‘I could liken you to a werewolf / The way you left me for dead / But I admit that I provided a full moon.’ I love the way her voice bounces off the words in time with her strong piano strokes, and of course her ending the song in a minor key.


9) Drumset

‘Drumset’ opens with the dreamlike strum of a harp, and from then we are met with the catchy, almost up-and-down sound of drums. The layering of vocals alongside the drumming makes the song addicting.


8) The Way Things Are

The run on When the Pawn… that is ‘Fast as You Can’ to ‘The Way Things Are’ to ‘Get Gone’ is a big reason why the album is one I find myself returning to. ‘The Way Things Are’ is my favourite of the three because of Apple’s unforgettable delivery of the bridge. The album recording is incredible already, but the live recordings are unreal.

There’s a great live version where Apple performs it as the closer. She’s almost screaming most of the lyrics and it feels so visceral, as if she’s accessing the memories of the pain in real time.


7) Paper Bag

‘Paper Bag’ was one of my first favourite songs by Apple. I used to glamorise the idea of being misunderstood by a lover (mind you, this was before I was anywhere close to having anything of the sort in my life). The lyrics, ‘He said it’s all in your head / And I said so’s everything, but he didn’t get it’, are so memorable. This song feels like a waltz of sorts, especially when watching the music video, directed by her ex, Paul Thomas Anderson.


6) Ladies

When I did my first listen-through of Fetch the Bolt Cutters, ‘Ladies’ was the first song that I mentally noted as my favourite. I remember I felt so strongly about the song that I made a playlist based off it. This song feels as though Apple is lecturing on the importance of women standing by one another rather than against. Her repetition of ‘ladies…ladies…’ comes across as being exhausted by the concept of women fighting each other over men. Exhaustion not because of annoyance, but because of understanding.


5) Criminal

‘Criminal’ is Apple’s most recognisable song. It’s hard to believe the song that sparked so much debate was written by Apple in only 45 minutes after execs told her to bring them an ‘obvious’ hit.

One of my favourite things about this song is the intro. It feels like we’ve been dropped in a Matrix movie. In the music video, we meet Apple’s gaze among a sea of limbs, the backs of partygoers’ heads, half-drunk bottles, but not a single other face. It’s as though Apple is forcing us to witness her atoning for her perceived sins.


4) Sleep to Dream

Through compiling this list, I have realised that almost all of my personal favourite Fiona Apple songs seem to be those where she is angriest. In ‘Sleep to Dream’, Apple reminds her former lover that she is not to be underestimated. As the opening track to Tidal, it sets the tone for the rest of the album.


3) The First Taste

Oh, to be a partygoer dancing behind Apple in the ‘The First Taste’ music video. It feels just shy of impossible to describe this song without first using the word ‘sexy’. The song feels like a spell, beckoning the targeted listener to come closer. It’s primal and jazzy, with some background electric guitar notes that feel like they could fit into a Santana song.

While the Apple songs I revisit most often are those where she is at her most intense, ‘The First Taste’ has the trancelike quality of a siren song that keeps you itching to dip more than your toes in the water.


2) Shadowboxer

Released as the first single off Tidal, ‘Shadowboxer’ was the world’s introduction to Apple. I cannot get enough of this song. It’s sultry, it’s vulnerable, and it’s her standing her ground.


1) I Want You to Love Me

And through it all, ‘I Want You to Love Me’ captivates me on a level that remains untouched. It is the encapsulation of who she is as an artist. She is introspective, but she never loses the context in which she is analysing herself. Apple pours herself into her writing and delivers it through raw vocals that almost feel strained at times by the weight of her words. All of this, accompanied by her engrossing, signature piano playing.

‘I Want You to Love Me’ welcomes us to the matured version of the ‘patron saint of reality’ Apple hoped to be. It’s impossible to separate her from her art. Her music is intertwined with how she sees the world. With an impassioned voice, she proclaims, ‘And I know when I go / All my particles disband and disperse / And I’ll be back in the pulse.’ I think the thing that keeps me coming back to this song is it feels like a love song to what it means to be human. To want to be loved, to know that you are a product of all that came before, and to know that it’s all a part of something greater.

Previous
Previous

30 Years of Trainspotting: How the Film's Soundtrack Gained a Life of Its Own

Next
Next

Epitaph for a Dying World: How Cosmo Sheldrake’s Score Shapes the Narrative of Digger